"If Overwatch didn't exist, I think LawBreakers would have had a shot": Gears of War lead blames Blizzard's hero shooter for his failed FPS

LawBreakers characters face each other, one coming from the sky with a flaming blade while the other stands below with a similar weapon
(Image credit: Boss Key Productions)

Six years after the untimely demise of first-person hero shooter LawBreakers, the game's director explains why he thinks Overwatch played a part in its failure.

You might know game designer Cliff 'Cliffy B' Bleszinski for his work on Gears of War or his time on the Unreal series. You may also remember the studio he headed after his work with Epic, Boss Key Productions - or its 2018 closure following the commercial failure of its debut title, LawBreakers. LawBreakers launched in 2017, a little over a year after Blizzard launched its own hit multiplayer FPS, Overwatch. Bleszinski now says that this unfortunate timing contributed to the downfall of Boss Key's debut game and that the title otherwise could've "had a shot."

Speaking to Edge, Bleszinski states that various factors likely fed into the shooter's demise. "Whenever an airplane crashes, it's usually multiple cascading failures." From a "crowded" market to a poor marketing campaign, the dev notes different reasons for LawBreakers' short life but points to the arrival of Overwatch in 2016 as the biggest of all. When Boss Key devs saw Blizzard's trailer, Bleszinski describes the collective thought process: "Oh god, we're fucked." While the studio's decision to include heroes and abilities in LawBreakers was inspired by its devs' hours playing MOBAs, it felt too close to Overwatch's style for comfort.

Hoping to draw a line between the two games' similarities, Bleszinski says his team tried to "zig" when Blizzard "zagged." No matter how many distinct features unique to Boss Key's game were found in everything from LawBreakers' heroes and their abilities to the shooter's overall aesthetic, nothing proved enough to prevent accusations of copying Overwatch. Bleszinski admits If he had known how, despite receiving generally positive reviews across the board, LawBreakers would fail to maintain an active audience, he'd have handled development differently. "I wouldn't have hired as many people," he explains. "I wouldn't have gone for a triple-A shooter."

Instead, the legendary dev says he'd "have made a little simple game" with a small team "to get something out the door" rather than spending a few years on a project like LawBreakers. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like Boss Key Production's title will spring back to life despite the designer's cryptic reference to it in 2023. Whether or not we see the Gears of War mastermind return to game development at all is yet to be determined, too. Bleszinski previously implied that he would be working on a new game, but later went on to delete teasers regarding the project and post that he's "kinda over the whole making games thing."

Want a shooter you can play now? Check out the best FPS games around.

Anna Koselke
Staff Writer

After spending years with her head in various fantastical realms' clouds, Anna studied English Literature and then Medieval History at the University of Edinburgh, going on to specialize in narrative design and video game journalism as a writer. She has written for various publications since her postgraduate studies, including Dexerto, Fanbyte, GameSpot, IGN, PCGamesN, and more. When she's not frantically trying to form words into coherent sentences, she's probably daydreaming about becoming a fairy druid and befriending every animal or she's spending a thousand (more) hours traversing the Underdark in Baldur's Gate 3. If you spot her away from her PC, you'll always find Anna with a fantasy book, a handheld video game console of some sort, and a Tamagotchi or two on hand.

Read more
The Fantastic Four seen running towards Dracula in Marvel Rivals' Season 1 'Eternal Night Falls' trailer.
It's time to stop calling Marvel Rivals an Overwatch 2 killer now that its features have already surpassed it
Screenshots of Overwatch 2 showing teams battling it out along with new perks and a Stadium game mode in action
"This is no longer about playing it safe": Overwatch 2 game director talks Marvel Rivals and betting big on season 15
Overwatch 2 sombra emp animation blizzard image
Marvel Rivals' success is actually "really great" for Overwatch 2, and the FPS's director says the "pressure" that Blizzard feels is mostly "internal"
Screenshots of Overwatch 2 showing teams battling it out along with new perks and a Stadium game mode in action
Marvel Rivals isn't going anywhere, so Overwatch 2 is stepping up with game-changing perks and a new mode that borrows from Counter-Strike and League of Legends
Overwatch 2 characters
10 games like Overwatch you'll want to squad up for
D.Va in Overwatch
Twitch star Shroud argues Overwatch is "absolutely a much better game" than Marvel Rivals, and "people forget" how good it was at launch: "That game took over the world"
Latest in FPS
Doom: The Dark Ages screenshot
Doom director claims The Dark Ages can be beaten without using a gun, but "the game's not necessarily built to do that"
Battlefield Bad Company 2
Battlefield dev reveals more of his Bad Company 3 script and confirms the plot would revolve around the squad getting kicked out of the military and brought back for a final suicide mission
A Titan readies for combat in an animated trailer for Apex Legends Season 19
Yet another Respawn shooter has reportedly been canceled, following the studio's Star Wars FPS and rumored Titanfall Legends game to the grave
A cropped screenshot from the pre-alpha gameplay footage shown in the 'Introducing Battlefield Labs' video.
Battlefield 6's first teaser takes me back to the days of Modern Warfare 2 lobbies and 24/7 Metro matches, proving we all crave a return to shooters' simpler times
Doom
Doom: The Dark Ages' new cutscenes exist because of fans' unlikely obsession with the series' lore: "A Doom game that doesn’t have a story is just an arcade game”
Battlefield Bad Company 2
"I am freaked out by how much might actually have been accurate": Battlefield Bad Company 3 writer unearths forgotten script
Latest in News
Rise of the Ronin's photo mode offers some wonderful shots
On the heels of Rise of the Ronin's PC launch, its director says there's a "significant" amount of Japanese Switch gamers: "I am closely watching how this will change with the release of Switch 2"
Stardew Valley Castle Village mod
Stardew Valley Expanded creator is building an "even more ambitious" mod with a whole new city and "dungeons inspired by The Legend of Zelda"
Dino Crisis 2 art showing a young woman and man back-to-back amid tall green grass, both with their weapons drawn
Dino Crisis gets a fresh trademark filing by Capcom, but it might not mean the 26-year-old survival horror franchise will get a new installment like fans expect
Cujo
Netflix is making a brand new adaptation of Cujo, the infamous Stephen King book about a killer dog
Dragon Age 2
Veteran Dragon Age dev says one big delay is better than several small ones: "You are laying band-aid on top of band-aid on top of band-aid"
Death Stranding 2: On the Beach
Dark Souls 2 fans remind Death Stranding 2 director Hideo Kojima that he won’t be taking the DS2 acronym that easily